X
Shelter Island
Click the calendars to choose your dates
Check-In
Check-Out
1
Adults
0
Children
1
Rooms
Click here if you don't know your dates
SUNSET BEACH
Shelter Island NY
$525
+1-855-375-4108
SUNSET BEACH 35 Shore Road
View all reviews
4 stars
The Chequit
Shelter Island Heights NY
$339
+1-855-375-4108
The Chequit 23 Grand Ave
View all reviews
3 stars
The Pridwin Hotel
Shelter Island Heights NY
$345
+1-855-375-4108
The Pridwin Hotel 81 Shore Road
View all reviews
3 stars
The Harborfront Inn
Greenport NY
$189
+1-855-375-4108
The Harborfront Inn 209 Front St
View all reviews
3 stars
The Menhaden
Greenport NY
$356
+1-855-375-4108
The Menhaden 207 Front St
View all reviews
3 stars
Sound View Greenport
Greenport NY
$417
+1-855-375-4108
Sound View Greenport 58775 Route 48
View all reviews
3 stars
Sag Harbor Inn
Sag Harbor NY
$271
+1-855-375-4108
Sag Harbor Inn 45 West Water Street
View all reviews
3 stars
Barons Cove
Sag Harbor NY
$351
+1-855-375-4108
Barons Cove 31 West Water Street
View all 328 reviews
3 stars
+1-855-375-4108
Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast 54300 County Route 48
View all reviews
3 stars
EHP Resort
East Hampton NY
$480
+1-855-375-4108
EHP Resort 295 Three Mile Harbor / Hog Creek Road
View all reviews
3 stars

Find Hotels in Shelter Island NY

Price
Sort
Sort
Rating
Sort
Stars
Sort
Suggestions For You
See All
Pet Friendly
6 Properties
View
Swimming Pools
2 Properties
View
Free Breakfast
7 Properties
View
View Nearby Cities
0 miles from Shelter Island
3 miles from Greenport
5 miles from East Marion
5 miles from Southold
5 miles from Sag Harbor
7 miles from Peconic
8 miles from Cutchogue
9 miles from Sagaponack
9 miles from Wainscott
9 miles from Bridgehampton
9 miles from New Suffolk
9 miles from Springs
10 miles from East Hampton
12 miles from Mattituck
12 miles from Amagansett
13 miles from Southampton