X

Shelter Island

Click the calendars to choose your dates

Check-In

Check-Out

1

Adults

0

Children

1

Rooms

Get Rates

Click here if you don't know your dates

>

SUNSET BEACH 35 Shore Road

View all reviews

4 stars

>

The Chequit 23 Grand Ave

View all reviews

3 stars

>

The Pridwin Hotel 81 Shore Road

View all reviews

3 stars

>

The Harborfront Inn 209 Front St

View all reviews

3 stars

>

The Menhaden 207 Front St

View all reviews

3 stars

>

Sound View Greenport 58775 Route 48

View all reviews

3 stars

>

Sag Harbor Inn 45 West Water Street

View all reviews

3 stars

>

4 rating

Barons Cove 31 West Water Street

View all 328 reviews

3 stars

>

Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast 54300 County Route 48

View all reviews

3 stars

>

EHP Resort 295 Three Mile Harbor / Hog Creek Road

View all reviews

3 stars

Find Hotels in Shelter Island NY

Price

Sort

Sort

Rating

Sort

Stars

Sort

Suggestions For You

See All

Pet Friendly

6 Properties

View

Swimming Pools

2 Properties

View

Free Breakfast

7 Properties

View

View Nearby Cities

>